When the sun starts to dip toward the Gulf horizon, the vibe in our corner of Florida shifts from sun-soaked relaxation to coastal romance. While we love a day at the beach, there is something uniquely special about an evening spent under the palms. If you are looking for seafood restaurants Venice locals choose for an authentic, high-vibe evening, Captain Eddie’s is your ultimate date night destination.
Here is how to plan a night that hits all the right notes.
The Soundtrack of Romance: Why Live Music Matters
Ever noticed how a great song can make a meal taste better? It’s not just your imagination. Venice live music adds a layer of “Old Florida” soul to your dinner that a playlist simply can’t replicate.
Whether it’s the soulful strumming of an acoustic guitar or a vibrant island rhythm, live music creates a natural “buffer” that allows for intimate conversation without feeling like the whole room is listening. At our Tiki Bar, the music sets a relaxed, celebratory tone that helps you leave the stress of the workweek behind the moment you sit down.
Check our Live Music Schedule to find the genre that fits your date night mood!
A Match Made in the Gulf: Wine & Maine Lobster
Nothing says “special occasion” like a lobster dinner. While we are famous for our local catches, our Maine Lobster remains a date night favorite for those seeking a touch of indulgence.
To elevate the experience, we recommend pairing your meal with one of our crisp house wines. A chilled Chardonnay or a light Pinot Grigio cuts through the richness of the drawn butter perfectly, highlighting the natural sweetness of the lobster meat. If you’re starting with appetizers at the bar, a glass of our house Rosé is a refreshing way to toast to the evening.
Step-by-Step Guide: The Ultimate “Tiki Bar Date”
Not sure how to structure your evening? Follow this simple “Captain’s Guide” for a flawless date night Venice FL experience:
- Step 1: The Sunset Toast (5:00 PM – 5:45 PM)
Arrive just as the golden hour begins. Grab two stools at the Tiki Bar and take advantage of the final hour of our Happy Hour (BOGO for $2 drink specials!). It’s the perfect time to catch up before the music starts. - Step 2: The Seafood Spread (6:00 PM – 7:15 PM)
Move to a table as the live music begins. Start with some fresh oysters or peel-and-eat shrimp, then dive into our signature Captain’s Platter or Thai Glazed Salmon. - Step 3: The Encore (7:30 PM – 8:30 PM)
As the band hits their stride, linger over a shared dessert, our Key Lime Pie is a must, and enjoy the cool Gulf breeze. - Step 4: The Stroll (Post-Dinner)
We are just a short drive from the water. After your meal, head toward Nokomis Beach for a moonlit walk to cap off the night.
Make it a Tradition
Whether it’s your first date or your 50th anniversary, the combination of fresh salt air, cold drinks, and local talent makes every visit feel like a getaway. Don’t settle for a quiet, stuffy dining room, come where the atmosphere is as fresh as the food.
Ready to plan your evening?
View our upcoming performers and book your table today. We can’t wait to be part of your love story!